Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (2024)

by Mary Neumann · 58 Comments

It’s the most wonderful time of the year, time to make my Grandpa Kelly’s Famous Horseradish Cheese Spread!

GRANDPA KELLY’S FAMOUS HORSERADISH CHEESE SPREAD

Only 4 Ingredients!! A cherished family recipe for over 50 years. We make this the week of Thanksgiving and it lasts until New Year’s Eve. One of my favorite family traditions. Skip the store bought bar cheese and make your own!

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (1)

I shared this recipe my first year blogging, it was one of my very first posts. I wanted to update a few of my photos and share it again for my new readers. If you love store bought Horseradish Bar Cheese, I know you will love this recipe. This is so much better than any store bought spread.

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (2)

Most families have foods or traditions that are must haves during the holidays. In my family, we have a few. The one that is most special to me, my official kick off to the holidays, is making my Grandpa Kelly’s Horseradish Cheese the week of Thanksgiving…ALWAYS with Jo Stafford playing in the background. I have been eating this cheese since my first two teeth popped through. I can’t remember a Thanksgiving or Christmas without this yummy spread.

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (3)

During one winter break back in college, while visiting my grandparents, a few years before my grandpa passed, he showed me how to make his “family secret” cheese. So shhhh, this is a secret!

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (4)

I’ve made this cheese for several parties and events over the years. I have also given it as holiday gifts in cute jars. People would always ask for the recipe, but I would never give it out – it’s a familysecret after all. Well, I did some googling on horseradish cheese…so much for the family secret. There has to be at least a dozensimilarrecipes on the internet. So since it’s already out there, I figure it’s okay to share.

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (5)


Only 4 ingredients and SO GOOD!!! Be sure to have a few containers, this recipe makes a lot and can be stored in the refrigerator from Thanksgiving to the New Year.

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (6)

PINNABLE IMAGE

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (7)

Horseradish Cheese Spread

  • 2 Pound Block ofVelveeta, cut into cubes
  • 1 CupHellmann’s®Real Mayonnaise (I only use Hellmann’s for this recipe)
  • 8 oz Fresh Prepared Horseradish (drain excess liquid on top)
  • 5-6 dashes ofTabascoSauce



Directions
Melt cheese in a double boiler. If you don’t have a double boiler, you can use a regular pan on medium heat, stirringcontinuouslyuntilcheese is melted and smooth. Remove from heat. Stir in mayonnaise, horseradish and Tabasco. Mix until completely blended. Pour into a small crocks or ceramic bowls. Chill. Serve with crackers. Store in refrigerator. Enjoy!

How easy is that?! And so so good!If you make the spread, please stop by and letting me know what you think.

Sharing this recipe at Weekend Potluck.

Thanks for stopping by!

Cheers!



More Bar Cheese recipe

  • Best Salad Ever (My Most Requested Salad Recipe)

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. Sandra McMahen

    Ok–Is the horseradish like the Kraft one sitting on the shelf in the grocery store OR the one that’s ground up and in the jars sitting cooler in the meat section??

    Reply

  2. Lois Childs

    How long will this last in
    1. Refrigerator?
    2. Freezer?
    THANK YOU

    Reply

    • Mary Neumann

      Refrigerator. Do Not Freeze.

      Reply

  3. Candy

    My first batch is cooling. I did lick the spoon (YUM) and can’t wait to try it on crackers. Horseradish doesn’t age well after it has been opened even tho it is refrigerated (it loses a lot of it’s zip) so if you want the spread to be zesty you might opt for a new jar.

    Reply

  4. Stephanie Nodelman

    This has been my go to “secret recipe” gift since I first saw it! Making another batch right now!

    Reply

    • Mary Neumann

      Smiling ear to ear, Stephanie 🙂

      Reply

  5. Lisaj

    How much of a ‘bite’ does this have?? 8oz of Horseradish seems like an awful lot!! (this, coming from someone that doesn’t like spicy food)

    Reply

    • Mary Neumann

      It all depends on how hot the horseradish is, be sure to use regular not extra hot. I have been eating this since I was little and was not a fan of hot/spicy foods until I was an adult.

      Reply

      • Mellissa

        Can you substitute either Greek yogurt or sour cream for the mayonnaise? I am going to a party that will have people with soy allergies

        Reply

        • Mary Neumann

          I do not think that would work, Melissa. The mayo is a big part of the cheese spread, I cannot think of a good substitute.

          Reply

  6. Ginny

    What are your favorite crudités to serve with this spread? Just put it in the fridge after tasting it warm. Delicious!

    Reply

    • Mary Neumann

      We grew up serving the spread with Triscuits and Sociable crackers – but veggies like celery, cucumbers and carrots would be great – peppers too.

      Reply

  7. Lauri Eide

    Can you substitute real cheese in place of Velveeta?

    Reply

    • Mary Neumann

      Lauri – I am not sure. This is how my Grandpa made it and the only way I’ve made all these years. I am not sure about texture with another cheese. You could try – I would just reduce the recipe to 1/4 for a trial run.

      Reply

  8. Nancy

    DELISH!!!

    Reply

  9. Joann

    Can this be made with another type of cheese instead of velveeta?

    Reply

  10. nancy

    DELISH!!!! The whole tribe raved about it!!

    Reply

  11. Nancy McCullough

    Can you do this recipe in a crock pot?

    Reply

    • Mary Neumann

      You could melt the cheese in a slow cooker, but it’s easy to just throw it in a pan on the stove – unless you don’t have access to stove, then a crock pot is a great solution. A double boiler is what my grandpa always used. I use a non stick pan on low to medium heat.

      Reply

      • Ella

        No, it can’t be! This is Grandma Jonnie’s secret family recipe I’ve been making for years! Grandma Jonnie gave it to ME, and me only! She always was a li’l’ stinker! Lol

        Reply

  12. Nancy

    Can I put this in a crockpot>

    Reply

  13. olivia

    Yumm, never had that.

    Reply

  14. Becky

    How long will this last in the fridge? Or could it be frozen?

    Reply

  15. marysweetlittlebluebird

    Hi Tiffany – It's a spread.

    Reply

  16. Tiffany

    Is this more of a dip (thinner) or a spread that you might use a knife to put it on the cracker?

    Reply

    • Mary Neumann

      It’s not thin but not hard – a slight more more firm than cream cheese once it’s cooled in the fridge.

      Reply

« Older Comments

Trackbacks

  1. […] found this recipe over at Sweet Little Bluebird and had to try it in the slow cooker, Mary got this recipe from her grandpa. I added pimentos for […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Horseradish Cheese Spread - Only 4 Ingredients (Grandpa Kelly's Famous Recipe) (2024)

FAQs

What kind of cheese is used for horseradish cheese? ›

A rich and creamy cheese spread, with a powerful horseradish and cheddar kick. A perfect appetizer for a big dinner or snack for a party. Serve cold with crusty bread or veggies.

Who makes horseradish cheddar cheese? ›

Taking inspiration from two favorites of traditional English fare, Boar's Head Bold Horseradish Cheddar Cheese is a culinary trip to the village pub. A delightful pairing of creamy, full-bodied cheddar cheese and piquant horseradish flavor, this cheese is an Old World delight.

What does horseradish cheddar cheese taste like? ›

At first you'll notice that this is by far our creamiest cheese yet, but then you'll get hit with a ridiculous amount of mouth-tingling horseradish. This skillfully-blended lactose-free cheese loves to be melted on an old-fashioned hamburger or to be served with gourmet cranberry chutney.

Does pub cheese have horseradish? ›

Horseradish adds a sharp bite to our blend of aged cheddar, milk and cream.

What's the difference between horseradish and creamy horseradish? ›

Prepared horseradish is made with grated horseradish root, vinegar, and salt. Prepared horseradish is not the same as horseradish sauce but is an ingredient in it. Horseradish sauce combines prepared horseradish with cream, sour cream, or mayonnaise, which makes it milder and creamier.

Does Havarti cheese have horseradish in it? ›

Surprising ingredients come to life in every bite of Horseradish Havarti. We combine a kick of flavor with fresh chives, horseradish and mustard seeds to surprise every taste bud.

What to pair with horseradish cheddar? ›

Simple to make, this great tasting spread is equally good with pretzels and crackers or fresh veggies. We love it paired with a hearty rye bread. But don't stop there! Try it as a condiment with grilled burgers and chicken or with cold vegetable and meat sandwiches.

What does horseradish cheese go good with? ›

Supremely creamy, with huge horseradish flavor, this is one delicious cheese! Adds unforgettable flavor to the ordinary sandwich, whether it's turkey, ham or roast beef.

What is the strongest cheddar cheese in the world? ›

Lymn Bank Strongest Cheddar Cheese

This two and half year old cheddar gives you an intense and lusciously tangy, savoury flavour. One of our more traditional Cheddar cheeses we stock but oh so delicious!

What cheese tastes most like cheddar? ›

How is Colby like cheddar? The cheese making process is actually quite similar to cheddar—specifically young cheddar. In terms of differences, Colby is generally softer and more elastic than cheddar, although it maintains a similarly mild flavor profile.

Is horseradish cheddar spicy? ›

Product Description: Horseradish Cheddar Cheese perfectly balances rich, nutty, and slightly sharp cheddar flavors with a spicy horseradish kick. It features cheddar's comforting creaminess, while the lingering heat sensation makes it a favorite for those seeking cheese with a spicy twist.

How long does boar's head horseradish last? ›

The official date for commercially prepared, bottled horseradish is 3 to 4 months after opening. However, there's a trick to know about horseradish. The bottled stuff loses potency pretty quickly after you open it.

What kind of cheese was the old government cheese? ›

Government cheese is "pasteurized process American cheese", a term with a standard of identity. It is produced from a variety of cheese (Cheddar cheese, Colby cheese, cheese curd, or granular cheese), made meltable using emulsifiers and blended.

Why is pub cheese so good? ›

Pub cheese is typically made with a hearty dose of cheese, beer, and a medley of spices or horseradish, which adds a fiery kick and massive flavor punch. It has a creamy texture and is super versatile: You can use it as a dip, melt it over fries or nachos, or even use it as a condiment for burgers and sandwiches.

What is a substitute for creamy horseradish? ›

For horseradish sauce, a good substitute is a creamy mustard, like Dijon mustard, spicy brown mustard, spicy mustard, or even horseradish mustard. Substitute using a 1:1 ratio. If you have a recipe that calls for ground horseradish, you will use ground mustard in equal parts instead.

What kind of cheese is used for hot pepper cheese? ›

Pepper Jack cheese is a delicious variant of the classic Monterey Jack cheese. It's a semi-soft, cow's milk cheese that has an open texture and a spicy taste. This spicy kick comes from the addition of jalapeño peppers, which are studded throughout the cheese.

What is the best cheese for stringy cheese? ›

What is a good stringy cheese when it's melted? Provolone is totally dope - down with these answers. I will also say young cheddar, low-moisture mozzarella (pizza cheese), Emmentaler, Raclette, and Gruyère. If you want to get freaky, TALEGGIO!

What is the best cheese for gooey pizza? ›

A combo of mozzarella and provolone offers both stretch and flavor; in fact, many pizzerias use just this blend. If stretch isn't important but you still favor an ooey-gooey melted cheese experience, any of the other tested cheeses should suit you just fine. Cheddar, fontina, Muenster, Gouda, etc.

What cheese is best for gooey? ›

Here's our top 10 list of cheeses that are the absolute best for melting, plus the recipes we love to use them in.
  • Swiss. ...
  • Fontina. ...
  • Monterey Jack. ...
  • Muenster. ...
  • Provolone. ...
  • Smoked Gouda. ...
  • Aged Cheddar. The older the Cheddar, the sharper it tastes. ...
  • Blue Cheese. Reach for this pungent speckled cheese when you want a core of bold flavor.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5763

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: The Hon. Margery Christiansen

Birthday: 2000-07-07

Address: 5050 Breitenberg Knoll, New Robert, MI 45409

Phone: +2556892639372

Job: Investor Mining Engineer

Hobby: Sketching, Cosplaying, Glassblowing, Genealogy, Crocheting, Archery, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is The Hon. Margery Christiansen, I am a bright, adorable, precious, inexpensive, gorgeous, comfortable, happy person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.